Newsweek Article - More Opinions On Somali Piracy - Coast Guard vs. Navy

Found this interesting article in Newsweek which suggests that the U.S. Coast Guard and not the Navy is better suited to address the Somali piracy situation.

The counterpiracy plan outlined Wednesday by Secretary of State Hillary Clinton was short on specifics, but long on nuance. Clinton committed to tracking and freezing the Somali bandits' finances—something that could prove difficult—while also working with shipping conglomerates and insurance companies to address "gaps in their self-defense measures." With a heavy military presence in the region all but off the table, given officials' remarks on the subject, what could that mean?

John Patch, a retired Navy commander who now teaches at the U.S. Army War College, has one possible answer. In the past few months, Patch has repeatedly said the global security threat posed by pirates is "overstated." But if Washington now feels compelled to respond to the surge in piracy in the Gulf of Aden, Patch argues, the best approach would be to treat the problem as a law-enforcement issue, not a military mission. NEWSWEEK's Katie Paul spoke to him about why, if the U.S. is to play any armed role in responding to the Somali pirates, the Coast Guard might be its best bet.

While the Coast Guard is likely the best maritime military force worldwide to address Somali piracy, bar none, it is plainly too small to take on another mission.  Law Enforcement Detachment (LEDETs) embarked on Navy or other allied ships could provide a crucial, internationally viable response to the pirate threat.  Endgame remains a vexing issue and absent political will for prosecution/incarceration in other countries, the Gulf of Aden's cat and mouse game will continue.

Comments

[Mike Hudson]

Interesting indeed. Rules of Engagement? CG cutter sees small go-fast with weapons speeding towards non-US flag vessel, say for example a Russian freighter, do they shoot? No doubt CG is best suited for mission based on LE competencies, although capacity to defend against and counterattack multiple high speed vessels with RPGs is a bit unproven. Of course, without additional resources of time and money, bit of a moot point.